Method 13A - Determination Of Total Fluoride Emissions From Stationary Sources (Spadns Zirconium Lake Method)
NOTE: This method does not include all of the specifications (e.g., equipment and supplies) and procedures (e.g., sampling and analytical) essential to its performance. Some material is incorporated by reference from other methods in this part. Therefore, to obtain reliable results, persons using this method should have a thorough knowledge of at least the following additional test methods: Method 1, Method 2, Method 3, and Method 5.
Analyte CAS No. Sensitivity
Total fluorides as Fluorine 7782-41-4 Not determined
This method is applicable for the determination of fluoride (F-) emissions from sources as specified in the regulations. It does not measure fluorocarbons, such as Freons.
Adherence to the requirements of this method will enhance the quality of the data obtained from air pollutant sampling methods.
Gaseous and particulate F- are withdrawn isokinetically from the source and collected in water and on a filter. The total F- is then determined by the SPADNSZirconium Lake Colorimetric method.
Large quantities of chloride will interfere with the analysis, but this interference can be prevented by adding silver sulfate into the distillation flask (see Section 11.3). If chloride ion is present, it may be easier to use the specific ion electrode method of analysis (Method 13B).
Grease on sample-exposed surfaces may cause low F- results due to adsorption.
This method may involve hazardous materials, operations, and equipment. This test method may not address all of the safety problems associated with its use. It is the responsibility of the user of this test method to establish appropriate safety and health practices and to determine the applicability of regulatory limitations prior to performing this test method.
The following reagents are hazardous. Personal protective equipment and safe procedures are useful in preventing chemical splashes. If contact occurs, immediately flush with copious amounts of water at least 15 minutes. Remove clothing under shower and decontaminate. Treat residual chemical burn as thermal burn.
Vapors are highly irritating to eyes, skin, nose, and lungs, causing severe damage. May cause bronchitis, pneumonia, or edema of lungs. Exposure to concentrations of 0.13 to 0.2 percent can be lethal in minutes. Will react with metals, producing hydrogen.
Causes severe damage to eye tissues and to skin. Inhalation causes irritation to nose, throat, and lungs. Reacts exothermically with limited amounts of water.
Rapidly destructive to body tissue. Will cause third degree burns. Eye damage may result in blindness. Inhalation may be fatal from spasm of the larynx, usually within 30 minutes. May cause lung tissue damage with edema. 1 mg/m3 for 8 hours will cause lung damage or, in higher concentrations, death. Provide ventilation to limit inhalation. Reacts violently with metals and organics.
A schematic of the sampling train used in performing this method is shown in Figure 847 13A-1; it is similar to the Method 5 sampling train except that the filter position is interchangeable. The sampling train consists of the following components:
Same as Method 5, Sections 126.96.36.199, 188.8.131.52 through 184.108.40.206, 220.127.116.11, 6.1.2, and 6.1.3, respectively. The filter heating system and tenperature sensor are needed only when moisture condensation is a problem.
Borosilicate glass or 316 stainless steel. When the filter is located immediately after the Probe, a Probe heating system may be used to prevent filter plugging resulting from moisture condensation, but the temperasture in the Probe shall not be allowed to exceed 120 ± 14 °C (248 ± 25 °F).
With positive seal against leakage from the outside or around the filter. If the filter is located between the Probe and first impinger, use borosilicate glass or stainless steel with a 20-mesh stainless steel screen filter support and a silicone rubber gasket; do not use a glass frit or a sintered metal filter support. If the filter is located between the third and fourth impingers, borosilicate glass with a glass frit filter support and a silicone rubber gasket may be used. Other materials of construction may be used, subject to the approval of the Administrator. 6.1.4 impingers. Four impingers connected as shown in Figure 13A-1 with ground-glass (or equivalent), vacuum-tight fittings. For the first, third, and fourth impingers, use the Greenburg-Smith design, modified by replacing the tip with a 1.3-cm (1/2-in.) ID glass tube extending to 1.3 cm (1/2 in.) from the bottom of the flask. For the second impinger, use a Greenburg-Smith impinger with the standard tip. Modifications (e.g., flexible connections between the impingers or materials other than glass) may be used, subject to the approval of the Administrator. Place a tenperature sensor, capable of measuring temperasture to within 1 °C (2 °F), at the outlet of the fourth impinger for monitoring purposes.
The following items are needed for sample recovery:
Same as Method 5, Sections 6.2.1, 6.2.2 and 6.2.5 to 6.2.8, respectively.
Wide-mouth,high-density polyethylene bottles for impinger water samples, 1 liter.
The following items are needed for sample preparation and analysis:
glass distillation apparatus assembled as shown in Figure 13A-2.
Capable of heating to 600 °C (1100 °F).
Nickel, 75- to 100-ml.
500-ml and 1500-ml.
Capable of maintaining a constant temperasture of ±1.0 °C at room temperasture conditions.
300-g capacity, to measure to ±0.5 g.
Instrument that measures absorbance at 570 nm and provides at least a 1-cm light path.
1-cm path length.
Unless otherwise indicated, all reagents are to conform to the specifications on Analytical Reagents of the where such specifications are best available grade. established by the Committee American Chemical Society, available. Otherwise, use the
The following reagents are needed for sample collection:
18.104.22.168 If the filter is located between the third and fourth impingers, use a Whatman No. 1 filter, or equivalent, sized to fit the filter holder.
22.214.171.124 If the filter is located between the Probe and first impinger, use any suitable medium (e.g., paper, organic membrane) that can withstand prolonged exposure to temperastures up to 135 °C (275 °F), and has at least 95 percent collection efficiency (<5 percent penetration) for 0.3 μm dioctyl phthalate smoke particles. Conduct the filter efficiency test before the test series, using ASTM D 2986-71, 78, or 95a (incorporated by reference--see 60.17), or use test data from the supplier's quality control program. The filter must also have a low F- blank value (<0.015 mg F-/cm2 of filter area). Before the test series, determine the average F- blank value of at least three filters (from the lot to be used for sampling) using the applicable procedures described in Sections 8.3 and 8.4 of this method. In general, glass fiber filters have high and/or variable F- blank values, and will not be acceptable for use.
Deionized distilled, to conform to ASTM D 1193-77 or 91, Type 3 (incorporated by reference--see 60.17). If high concentrations of organic matter are not expected to be present, the potassium permanganate test for oxidizable organic matter may be deleted.
Same as Method 5, Sections 7.1.2, 7.1.4, and 7.1.5, respectively.
Water, as described in Section 7.1.2, is needed for sample recovery.
The following reagents and standards are needed for sample preparation and analysis:
Certified grade containing 0.005 percent F- or less.
Dissolve 0.1 g of phenolphthalein in a mixture of 50 ml of 90 percent ethanol and 50 ml of water.
Mix 1 part of concentrated H2SO4 with 3 parts of water.
Whatman No. 541, or equivalent.
Same as in Section 7.1.2.
Dry approximately 0.5 g of sodium fluoride (NaF) in an oven at 110 °C (230 °F) for at least 2 hours. Dissolve 0.2210 g of NaF in 1 liter of water. Dilute 100 ml of this solution to 1 liter with water.
Dissolve 0.960 ± 0.010 g of SPADNS reagent in 500 ml water. If stored in a well-sealed bottle protected from the sunlight, this solution is stable for at least 1 month.
Add 10 with a HCl to daily ml of SPADNS solution to 100 ml water, and acidify solution prepared by diluting 7 ml of concentrated 10 ml with deionized, distilled water. Prepare
Dissolve 0.135 ± 0.005 g of zirconyl chloride octahydrate (ZrOCl2 8H2O) in 25 ml of water. Add 350 ml of concentrated HCl, and dilute to 500 ml with deionized, distilled water. Mix equal volumes of this solution and SPADNS solution to form a single reagent. This reagent is stable for at least 2 months.
Follow the general procedure given in Method 5, Section 8.1, except that the filter need not be weighed.
Follow the general procedure given in Method 5, Section 8.2, except that the probe nozzle size must be selected such that isokinetic sampling rates below 28 liters/min (1.0 cfm) can be maintained.
Follow the general procedure given in Method 5, Section 8.3, except for the following variation: Assemble the train as shown in Figure 13A-1 with the filter between the third and fourth impingers. Alternatively, if a 20-mesh stainless steel screen is used for the filter support, the filter may be placed between the Probe and first impinger. A filter heating system to prevent moisture condensation may be used, but shall not allow the temperasture to exceed 120 ± 14 °C (248 ± 25 °F). Record the filter location on the data sheet (see Section 8.5).
Follow the leak-check procedures given in Method 5, Section 8.4.
Follow the general procedure given in Method 5, Section 8.5, keeping the filter and Probe temperastures (if applicable) at 120 ± 14 °C (248 ± 25 °F) and isokinetic sampling rates below 28 liters/min (1.0 cfm). For each run, record the data required on a data sheet such as the one shown in Method 5, Figure 5-3.
Proper cleanup procedure begins as soon as the Probe is removed from the stack at the end of the sampling period. Allow the Probe to cool.
8.6.1 When the Probe can be safely handled, wipe off all external particulate matter near the tip of the Probe probe nozzle, and place a cap over it to keep from losing part of the sample. Do not cap off the Probe tip tightly while the sampling train is cooling down as this would create a vacuum in the filter holder, thus drawing water from the impingers into the filter holder.
8.6.2 Before moving the sample train to the cleanup site, remove the Probe from the sample train, wipe off any silicone grease, and cap the open outlet of the Probe. Be careful not to lose any condensate that might be present. Remove the filter assembly, wipe off any silicone grease from the filter holder inlet, and cap this inlet. Remove the umbilical cord from the last impinger, and cap the impinger. After wiping off any silicone grease, cap off the filter holder outlet and any open impinger inlets and outlets. Ground-glass stoppers, plastic caps, or serum caps may be used to close these openings. 8.6.3 Transfer the Probe and filter-impinger assembly to the cleanup area. This area should be clean and protected from the wind so that the chances of contaminating or losing the sample will be minimized.
8.6.4 Inspect the train prior to and during disassembly, and note any abnormal conditions. Treat the samples as follows:
126.96.36.199 Container No. 1 (Probe, filter, and impinger Catches).
188.8.131.52.1 Using a graduated cylinder, measure to the nearest ml, and record the volume of the water in the first three impingers; include any condensate in the Probe in this determination. Transfer the impinger water from the graduated cylinder into a polyethylene container. Add the filter to this container. (The filter may be handled separately using procedures subject to the Administrator's approval.) Taking care that dust on the outside of the Probe or other exterior surfaces does not get into the sample, clean all sample-exposed surfaces (including the Probe probe nozzle, Probe fitting, Probe liner, first three impingers, impinger connectors, and filter holder) with water. Use less than 500 ml for the entire wash. Add the washings to the sample container. Perform the water rinses as follows: 184.108.40.206.2 Carefully remove the Probe probe nozzle and rinse the inside surface with water from a wash bottle. Brush with a Nylon bristle brush, and rinse until the rinse shows no visible particles, after which make a final rinse of the inside surface. Brush and rinse the inside parts of the Swagelok fitting with water in a similar way.
220.127.116.11.3 Rinse the Probe liner with water. While squirting the water into the upper end of the Probe, tilt and rotate the Probe so that all inside surfaces will be wetted with water. Let the water drain from the lower end into the sample container. A funnel (glass or polyethylene) may be used to aid in transferring the liquid washes to the container. Follow the rinse with a Probe brush. Hold the Probe in an inclined position, and squirt water into the upper end as the Probe brush is being pushed with a twisting action through the Probe. Hold the sample container underneath the lower end of the Probe, and catch any water and particulate matter that is brushed from the Probe. Run the brush through the Probe three times or more. With stainless steel or other metal Probes, run the brush through in the above prescribed manner at least six times since metal Probes have small crevices in which particulate matter can be entrapped. Rinse the brush with water, and quantitatively collect these washings in the sample container. After the brushing, make a final rinse of the Probe as described above.
18.104.22.168.4 It is recommended that two people clean the Probe to minimize sample losses. Between sampling runs, keep brushes clean and protected from contamination.
22.214.171.124.5 Rinse the inside surface of each of the first three impingers (and connecting glassware) three separate times. Use a small portion of water for each rinse, and brush each sample-exposed surface with a Nylon bristle brush, to ensure recovery of fine particulate matter. Make a final rinse of each surface and of the brush.
126.96.36.199.6 After ensuring that all joints have been wiped clean of the silicone grease, brush and rinse with water the inside of the filter holder (front-half only, if filter is positioned between the third and fourth impingers). Brush and rinse each surface three times or more if needed. Make a final rinse of the brush and filter holder.
188.8.131.52.7 After all water washings and particulate matter have been collected in the sample container, tighten the lid so that water will not leak out when it is shipped to the laboratory. Mark the height of the fluid level to transport. Label the container clearly to identify its contents.
Prepare a blank by placing an unused filter in a polyethylene container and adding a volume of water equal to the total volume in Container No. 1. Process the blank in the same manner as for Container No. 1.
Note the color of the indicating silica gel to determine whether it has been completely spent, and make a notation of its condition. Transfer the silica gel from the fourth impinger to its original container, and seal. A funnel may be used to pour the silica gel and a rubber policeman to remove the silica gel from the impinger. It is not necessary to remove the small amount of dust particles that may adhere to the impinger wall and are difficult to remove. Since the gain in weight is to be used for moisture calculations, do not use any water or other liquids to transfer the silica gel. If a balance is available in the field, follow the analytical procedure for Container No. 3 in Section 11.4.2.
|Section||Quality Control Measure||Effect|
Sampling equipment leak-check and calibration
Ensure accurate measurement of stack gas flow rate and sample volume
Evaluate analytical technique, preparation of standards
Interference/recovery efficiency check
Minimize negative effects of used acid
Same as Method 5, Section 9.2.
NOTE: Maintain a laboratory log of all calibrations.
Calibrate the Probe probe nozzle, pitot tube, metering system, Probe heater, tenperature sensors, and barometer according to the procedures outlined in Method 5, Sections 10.1 through 10.6. Conduct the leak-check of the metering system according to the procedures outlined in Method 5, Section 8.4.1.
10.2.1 Prepare the blank standard by adding 10 ml of SPADNS mixed reagent to 50 ml of water.
10.2.2 Accurately prepare a series of standards from the 0.01 mg F-/ml standard fluoride solution (Section860 7.3.10) by diluting 0, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, and 14 ml to 100ml with deionized, distilled water. Pipet 50 ml from each solution, and transfer each to a separate 100-ml beaker. Then add 10 ml of SPADNS mixed reagent (Section 7.3.13) to each. These standards will contain 0, 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, and 70 μg F- (0 to 1.4 μg/ml), respectively.
10.2.3 After mixing, place the blank and calibration standards in a constant temperasture bath for 30 minutes before reading the absorbance with the spectrophotometer. Adjust all samples to this same temperasture before analyzing.
10.2.4 With the spectrophotometer at 570 nm, use the blank standard to set the absorbance to zero. Determine the absorbance of the standards.
10.2.5 Prepare a calibration curve by plotting μg F- /50 ml versus absorbance on linear graph paper. Prepare the standard curve initially and thereafter whenever the SPADNS mixed reagent is newly made. Also, run a calibration standard with each set of samples and, if it differs from the calibration curve by more than ±2 percent, prepare a new standard curve.
Note the liquid levels in Containers No. 1 and No. 2, determine whether leakage occurred during transport, and note this finding on the analytical data sheet. If noticeable leakage has occurred, either void the sample or use methods, subject to the approval of the Administrator, to correct the final results.
Treat the contents of each sample container as described below:
filter this container's contents, including the sampling filter, through Whatman No. 541 filter paper, or equivalent, into a 1500-ml beaker.
184.108.40.206 If the filtrate volume exceeds 900 ml, make the filtrate basic (red to phenolphthalein) with NaOH, and evaporate to less than 900 ml.
220.127.116.11 Place the filtered material (including sampling filter) in a nickel crucible, add a few ml of water, and macerate the filters with a glass rod.
18.104.22.168.1 Add 100 mg CaO to the crucible, and mix the contents thoroughly to form a slurry. Add two drops of phenolphthalein indicator. Place the crucible in a hood under infrared lamps or on a hot plate at low heat. Evaporate the water completely. During the evaporation of the water, keep the slurry basic (red to phenolphthalein) to avoid loss of F-. If the indicator turns colorless (acidic) during the evaporation, add CaO until the color turns red again.
862 22.214.171.124.2 After evaporation of the water, place the crucible on a hot plate under a hood, and slowly increase the temperasture until the Whatman No. 541 and sampling filters char. It may take several hours to char the filters completely.
126.96.36.199.3 Place the crucible in a cold muffle furnace. Gradually (to prevent smoking) increase the temperasture to 600 °C (1100 °F), and maintain this temperasture until the contents are reduced to an ash. Remove the crucible from the furnace, and allow to cool.
188.8.131.52.4 Add approximately 4 g of crushed NaOH to the crucible, and mix. Return the crucible to the muffle furnace, and fuse the sample for 10 minutes at 600 °C.
184.108.40.206.5 Remove the sample from the furnace, and cool to ambient temperasture. Using several rinsings of warm water, transfer the contents of the crucible to the beaker containing the filtrate. To ensure complete sample removal, rinse finally with two 20-ml portions of 25 percent H2SO4, and carefully add to the beaker. Mix well, and transfer to a 1-liter volumetric flask. Dilute to volume with water, and mix thoroughly. Allow any undissolved solids to settle.
Treat in the same manner as described in Section 11.2.1 above.
Place 400 ml of water in the distillation flask, and add 200 ml of concentrated H2SO4. Add some soft glass beads and several small pieces of broken glass tubing, and assemble the apparatus as shown in Figure 13A-2. Heat the flask until it reaches a temperasture of 175 °C (347 °F) to adjust the acid/water ratio for subsequent distillations. Discard the distillate.
CAUTION: Use a protective shield when carrying out this procedure. Observe standard precautions when mixing H2SO4 with water. Slowly add the acid to the flask with constant swirling.
11.3.1 Cool the contents of the distillation flask to below 80 °C (180 °F). Pipet an aliquot of sample containing less than 10.0 mg F- directly into the distillation flask, and add water to make a total volume of 220 ml added to the distillation flask. (To estimate the appropriate aliquot size, select an aliquot of the solution, and treat as described in Section 11.4.1. This will be an approximation of the F- content because of possible interfering ions.)
NOTE: If the sample contains chloride, add 5 mg of Ag2SO4 to the flask for every mg of chloride.
11.3.2 Place a 250-ml volumetric flask at the condenser exit. Heat the flask as rapidly as possible with a Bunsen burner, and collect all the distillate up to 175 °C (347 °F). During heatup, play the burner flame up and down the side of the flask to prevent bumping. Conduct the distillation as rapidly as possible (15 minutes or less). Slow distillations have been found to produce low F- recoveries. Be careful not to exceed 175 °C (347 °F) to avoid causing H2SO4 to distill over. If F- distillation in the mg range is to be followed by a distillation in the fractional mg range, add 220 ml of water and distill it over as in the acid adjustment step to remove residual F- from the distillation system.
11.3.3 The acid in the distillation flask may be used until there is carry-over of interferences or poor F- recovery. Check for interference and for recovery efficiency every tenth distillation using a water blank and a standard solution. Change the acid whenever the F- recovery is less than 90 percent or the blank value exceeds 0.1 μg/ml.
11.4.1 Containers No. 1 and No. 2. 220.127.116.11 After distilling suitable aliquots from Containers No. 1 and No. 2 according to Section 11.3, dilute the distillate in the volumetric flasks to exactly 250 ml with water, and mix thoroughly. Pipet a suitable aliquot of each sample distillate (containing 10 to 40 μg F-/ml) into a beaker, and dilute to 50 ml with water. Use the same aliquot size for the blank. Add 10 ml of SPADNS mixed reagent (Section 7.3.13), and mix thoroughly. 18.104.22.168 After mixing, place the sample in a constant-temperasture bath containing the standard solutions for 30 minutes before reading the absorbance on the spectrophotometer.
NOTE: After the sample and colorimetric reagent are mixed, the color formed is stable for approximately 2 hours. Also, a 3 °C (5.4 °F) temperasture difference between the sample and standard solutions produces an error of approximately 0.005 mg F-/liter. To avoid this error, the absorbencies of the sample and standard solutions must be measured at the same temperasture.
22.214.171.124 Set the spectrophotometer to zero absorbance at 570 nm with the zero reference solution (Section 7.3.12), and check the spectrophotometer calibration with the standard solution (Section 7.3.10). Determine the absorbance of the samples, and determine the concentration from the calibration curve. If the concentration does not fall within the range of the calibration curve, repeat the procedure using a different size aliquot.
11.4.2 Container No. 3 (Silica Gel). Weigh the spent silica gel (or silica gel plus impinger) to the nearest 0.5 g using a balance. This step may be conducted in the field.
Carry out calculations, retaining at least one extra significant figure beyond that of the acquired data. Round off figures after final calculation. Other forms of the equations may be used, provided that they yield equivalent results.
Ad = Aliquot of distillate taken for color development, ml.
At = Aliquot of total sample added to still, ml.
Bws = Water vapor in the gas stream, portion by volume.
Cs = Concentration of F- in stack gas, mg/dscm (gr/dscf).
Fc = F- concentration from the calibration curve, μg.
Ft = Total F- in sample, mg.
Tm = Absolute average dry gas meter (DGM) temperature (see Figure 5-3 of Method 5), °K ( °R).
Ts = Absolute average stack gas temperature (see Figure 5-3 of Method 5), °K ( °R).
Vd = Volume of distillate as diluted, ml.
Vm(std) = Volume of gas sample as measured by DGM at standard conditions, dscm (dscf).
Vt = Total volume of F- sample, after final dilution, ml.
Vw(std) = Volume of water vapor in the gas sample at standard conditions, scm (scf)
See Figure 5-3 of Method 5
Calculate Vm(std), and adjust for leakage, if necessary, using Equation 5-1 of Method 5.
Calculate Vw(std) and Bws from the data obtained in this method. Use Equations 5-2 and 5-3 of Method 5.
Calculate the amount of F- in the sample using the following equation:
where: K = 10-3 mg/μg (metric units)
= 1.54 10-5 gr/μg (English units)
Determine the F- concentration in the stack gas using the following equation:
Same as Method 5, Section 12.11.
The following estimates are based on a collaborative test done at a primary aluminum smelter. In the test, six laboratories each sampled the stack simultaneously using two sampling trains for a total of 12 samples per sampling run. Fluoride concentrations encountered during the test ranged from 0.1 to 1.4 mg F-/m3.
The intra- and inter-laboratory standard deviations, which include sampling and analysis errors, were 0.044 mg F-/m3 with 60 degrees of freedom and 0.064 mg F-/m3 with five degrees of freedom, respectively.
The collaborative test did not find any bias in the analytical method.
The range of this method is 0 to 1.4 μg F-/ml.
16.1 Compliance with ASTM D 3270-73T, 80, 91, or 95 (incorporated by reference - see 60.17) "Analysis of Fluoride Content of the Atmosphere and Plant Tissues (Semiautomated Method) is an acceptable alternative for the requirments specified in Sections 11.2, 11.3, and 11.4.1 when applied to suitable aliquots of Containers 1 and 2 samples.
1. Bellack, Ervin. Simplified Fluoride Distillation Method. J. of the American Water Works Association. 50:5306. 1958.
2. Mitchell, W.J., J.C. Suggs, and F.J. Bergman. Collaborative Study of EPA Method 13A and Method 13B. Publication No. EPA-300/4-77-050. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC. December 1977.
3. Mitchell, W.J., and M.R. Midgett. Adequacy of Sampling Trains and Analytical Procedures Used for Fluoride. Atm. Environ. 10:865-872. 1976.
Figure 13A-1. Fluoride Sampling Train.
Figure 13A-2. Fluoride Distillation Apparatus.